Merrython was initial part of World Finest's Wrestling's pay per view schedule. When WFW and New ERA of Wrestling merged to form the WFW:NE on June 1, 2009, the event was kept as part of the pay per view rotation. However, when the WFW left WFW:NE and became NGEN, it took Merrython with it. Staple matches of the pay per view include the FAO Schwartz match where the match takes place inside FAO Schwartz, and a Winter Wonderland match that takes place in Central Park.
The 2004 pay per view was broadcast from December 30, 2003 to January 2, 2004. The first Merrython is widely regarded as one of WFW's finest pay per views. It featured the very first Santa's Sack o' Weapons match, the first Santa's Surprise match, and the first FAO Schwartz and Winter Wonderland matches.
Larry Tact defeated Pulsar.
Felix Red and Richard Gideon defeated Rat Fink and Psycho.
Barbwired Cage Street Fight match
Copycat defeated Anarky.
Santa's Sack o' Weapons match
Michael Manson, El Arco Iris and Good Eddie defeated Luster, Terrell Mason and Minion.
Santa's Surprise match
Alex Wylde defeated Jared Wells and "Simply Sensational" Sean Edmunds.
FAO Schwartz match
"The Viewer's Choice" Scotty Michaels defeated "The Phenom" Shawn Hart (c).
The 2005 pay per view was broadcast from March 3, 2005 to April 5, 2005. The second Merrython featured ten huge matches including two epic affairs for #1 contender positions. The main event featured a Winter Wonderland match where Steve Savoy (aka Shawn Hart) went 0-2 in the event after losing to Copycat. The event did not feature three of the "gimmick" matches held at the first Merrython due to the fact that some of them were held at WFW Christmas Card only a show before.
Pitt defeated Ron Artest.
The Silencer defeated Akira's Ghost.
Unnamed Bastard and Luster defeated Aaron Rage and Steve Johnson
Tag Team match
The Cameron Cruise Project and Rocko Daymon defeated Jean Rabesque, Adam Benjamin and Sebastian Dodd.
Six Man Tag match
Golden Hawk defeated Mighty Impala.
John Doe and Pulsar defeated Golem and Noble Sheik.
Tag Team match
Bloodhunt defeated Felix Red.
Anarky defeated "Simply Sensational" Sean Edmunds.